Tony West’s Departure Ends Era of Pathetic Bank Settlements

By David Dayen, a lapsed blogger, now a freelance writer based in Los Angeles, CA. Follow him on Twitter @ddayen

With the imminent departure of Tony West from the Justice Department, we can assuredly close the book on this latest round of financial fraud settlements. West was a co-chair of the vaunted task force known as the RMBS Working Group: of the original members, only U.S. Attorney for Colorado John Walsh and New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman remain. And West was the point person inside the Justice Department for the JPMorgan, Citigroup and Bank of America cases (“Top Nemesis of Big Banks,” screams the New York Times for some reason).

There were surely more banks selling RMBS than those three – the Federal Housing Finance Agency sued 17 of them – but without West’s, er, leadership, I wouldn’t expect any further action. Especially given the other prosecutors heading for the exits, including Antonia Apps, the lead lawyer in the SAC Capital case, and Jeffrey Knox, the I would assume lonely head of the criminal-fraud division. Both hooked on with white-collar legal defense practices.

With the end upon us, we can therefore assess this working group and their efforts. We know the raw numbers you see in headlines – $36.65 billion spread among the three settlements. We also know that these numbers are wrong. The JPMorgan settlement includes the $4 billion agreement with FHFA, even though it was settled weeks before DoJ announced. Yves quite properly coined the phrase “bullshit to cash ratio” to describe how the consumer relief portions of the settlement – where banks can use other people’s money, get credit for routine operations like donating homes and even money-making enterprises like making loans, and satisfy their obligations through HAMP loans that allows them to collect incentive payments – look nothing like any kind of penalty you would see in any other format. No bank robber is told that he can serve out his sentence by opening a lemonade stand.

When you weed out the bullshit, you get $5 billion from JPMorgan, $4.5 billion from Citi and $9.65 billion from BofA. And that’s before you take into account the tax deductibility. My initial estimates for the tax savings were $2.66 billion for JPM. About $1 billion of the Citi settlement will be offset by tax savings, and around $4 billion for BofA. So that’s $7.66 billion in offsets.

Let’s do the math!

$5 billion + $4.5 billion + $9.65 billion = $19.15 billion
$19.15 billion – $7.66 billion = $11.49 billion.

We’ll round up for convenience’s sake. So that’s $11.5 billion in penalties – almost all of them to the Justice Department themselves, and none to the actual investors in mortgage-backed securities who got swindled. That’s the results from nearly three years of work involving multiple DoJ divisions, U.S. Attorney’s offices and state AGs around the country. For context, just in 2013, Citigroup, the smallest of these three banks, recorded a profit of $14.39 billion. Their share of the penalty is $3.5 billion. It’s a blip, and I doubt it covers even a fraction of what they made in MBS sales.

I know it’s fun for the financial press to characterize Tony West as this heroic swashbuckler, fending off bank lawyers and leaping over C-suite executives in a single bound, but he was a lifeline to an industry seeking only to shed their legal exposure and move forward. Now, with that work done, with nobody coming close to seeing the inside of a jail cell, West can ride off into the private sector. And this is a bit of a giveaway as to his next move:

Mr. West has hired Robert B. Barnett, the famed Washington lawyer whose client list includes President Clinton, Sarah Palin and Bob Woodward, according to people briefed on the matter. Mr. Barnett, who acts as a career counselor of sorts to political and media elite, is expected to help Mr. West, 49, land his next job.

Barnett is a top-notch Washington fixer. Wherever he lands, West will be well-positioned. Maybe he’ll join Lanny Breuer and Mythili Raman at Covington & Burling (where I assume they’re keeping a seat warm for Eric Holder, or maybe he’ll come back to California – he’s our AG Kamala Harris’ brother-in-law – and use these weak-ass settlements as the springboard to a political career. Maybe I’ll have to do an ad with the “Bank Settlement Veterans for Truth” or something.

Ultimately, I don’t hold West responsible for this debacle. He probably had a hand in setting the policy, but the fish rots from the head down. We’ve known for many years that banks would escape the financial crisis without so much as having to come clean on the nature of their crimes and the extent of the damage caused. West just executed on this strategy. And for that, he’ll be rewarded.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
This entry was posted in Banana republic, Banking industry, Guest Post, Regulations and regulators on by .

About David Dayen

David is a contributing writer to He has been writing about politics since 2004. He spent three years writing for the FireDogLake News Desk; he’s also written for The New Republic, The American Prospect, The Guardian (UK), The Huffington Post, The Washington Monthly, Alternet, Democracy Journal and Pacific Standard, as well as multiple well-trafficked progressive blogs and websites. His has been a guest on MSNBC, CNN, Aljazeera, Russia Today, NPR, Pacifica Radio and Air America Radio. He has contributed to two anthology books, one about the Wisconsin labor uprising and another on the fight against the Stop Online Piracy Act in Congress. Prior to writing about politics he worked for two decades as a television producer and editor. You can follow him on Twitter at @ddayen.


  1. participant-observer-observed

    “With the imminent departure of Tony West from the Justice Department, we can assuredly close the book on this latest round of financial fraud settlements. ”

    Except for the cynical but sad fact that we can expect him to do an Eric Cantor and canter his way to a Wall Street job, where the next round of financial fraud strategies and ALEC legislative prostitution rings and DC puppet stringers can again play on out, just in time for him or another like him to go back to DC and turn all sordid indictments into tea at three!

  2. Joe Marcinkowski

    Time to bring Bill Black Back – helped put many of Savings and Loan Officers in Jail
    author of “Best way to Rob a Bank, is to Own One”

  3. Chauncey Gardiner

    Thank you for this post, David Dayen. I read this and am disgusted. The primary purpose of such legal action as was discussed here is deterrence. That almost certainly has not been accomplished.

  4. frosty zoom

    ” but the fish rots from the head down.”

    yep. the eyes go first.


    ¿why is the word “conviction” not found on this page?

  5. Sluggeaux

    I prefer to avoid making personal ad hominem attacks as anonymous comments, but given what I have read here I feel that I must speak up. I can say from personal experience that Mr. West is the dictionary definition of an “empty suit” whose only talent seems to be an insatiable appetite for self-promotion. He was well-chosen by those who wanted nothing to happen to the banks and he will be well-rewarded by the very people he was duty-bound to investigate and prosecute. The fish does indeed rot from the head.

Comments are closed.