By Jerri-Lynn Scofield, who has worked as a securities lawyer and a derivatives trader. She is currently writing a book about textile artisans.
We’re number one!
The U.S. remains the world’s largest plastic waste exporter – even though waste exports have declined significantly since China decided in 2018 not to continue to be the world’s dumping ground for plastic waste. Other countries – Vietnam, Thailand – have taken up some of the slack.
In fact, the U.S. continues to generate more plastic waste exports than all other EU countries combined.
The Guardian reported Friday that Latin America environmental organizations have called for the U.S. to curb its plastic waste exports to the region, after a report conducted by the Last Beach Cleanup, a California-based environmental advocacy group, found that plastic waste exports from the U.S. had doubled to some Latin American countries during the first seven months of 2020 (see Latin America urges US to reduce plastic waste exports to region).
According to the Guardian:
More than 75% of imports to the region arrive in Mexico, which received more than 32,650 tons (29,620 metric tonnes) of plastic waste from the US between January and August 2020. El Salvador was second, with 4,054 tons, and Ecuador third, with 3,665 tons, according to research carried out by the Last Beach Cleanup, an environmental advocacy group based in California.
While hazardous waste imports are subject to tariffs and restrictions, they are seldom enforced and plastic waste intended for recycling – which until January this year was not considered hazardous under international law – that enters importing countries can often end up as landfill, according to a researchers with the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (Gaia).
A Gaia report published in July also predicted further growth in the plastic waste sector in Latin America due to companies in the US and China investing in factories and recycling plants across the region to process the US plastic exports.
Dumping plastic in developing countries is just a modern day manifestation of a colonialist attitude. Per the Guardian:
Some view the practice as a form of environmental colonialism. “The cross-border plastic waste trade is perhaps one of the most nefarious expressions of the commercialisation of common goods and the colonial occupation of territories of the geopolitical south to turn them into sacrifice zones,” said Fernanda Solíz, the health area director at the Simón Bolívar University in Ecuador.
“Latin America and the Caribbean are not the back yards of the United States,” Soliz said. “We are sovereign territories, and we demand the respect of the rights of nature and our peoples.”
Other developed countries have tried to stem plastics waste exports, and in fact, produced an international agreement to that effect. Alas, the United States – the biggest plastics transgressor – opted not to sign on to that agreement. According to the Guardian:
Most of the world’s countries agreed in May 2019 to stem the flow of plastic waste from the developed nations of the global north into the poorer ones of the global south. Known as the plastics amendment to the Basel Convention, the agreement prohibited the export of plastic waste from private entities in the US to those in developing nations without the permission of local governments.
But critically, the US did not ratify the agreement, and has been accused of continuing to funnel its waste into countries around the world, including in Africa, south-east Asia, and Latin America.
“Regional governments fail in two aspects: the first is inspections at customs because we don’t really know what enters the country under the guise of recycling, and they also fail in their commitments with international agreements such as the Basel convention.” said Camila Aguilera, a spokesperson for Gaia. “And here it is important to see what comes under the types of recycling because recycling is seen as a good thing.”
“Countries in the global north see recycling as something to be proud of, forgetting about redesigning the products and reducing waste,” said Aguilera. “It’s very difficult for governments to treat plastic like toxic waste, but that’s what it is.”
I’m sorry to see the continued emphasis on recycling extended to Latin America, by US. and Chinese companies, which are promoting recycling as a means for dealing with waste generated in the U.S. At best, recycling is a half-measure. The world doesn’t need more voices singing in the recycling choir. Instead, it’s necessary to reduce plastics production. Full stop. Generating plastics in the first instance carries an environemenral cost. Far better to stop creating plastics rather then worrying about how to dispose of waste once created.