Yves here. This post not only provides some facts about the history and present state of prison labor in America, but also the costs that incarceration imposes on families.
And let us not forget:
Kamala locked up so many people, the Supreme Court ruled her prisons were unconstitutionally overcrowded.
She not only refused to release folks, she argued that her prison labor (legal slavery, by definition), was too profitable to give up. 6/ pic.twitter.com/McOY2BQiy0
— Hold Dems Accountable (@PushDemsLeft) July 29, 2024
Harris was remarkably open about her priorities. But as you will see, she has plenty of company.
By Bianca Tylek, the author of The Prison Industry: How It Works and Who Profits, and the Founder and Executive Director of Worth Rises, a national non-profit dismantling the prison industry and ending the exploitation of those it touches Originally published at openDemcracy
In the United States, freedom has never been free. For Black Americans, in particular, the price of freedom has been immense, paid through generations of impossible decisions and forced compromises with the loss of history, family unity, financial stability, and privacy.
Costs that emerged in efforts to escape chattel slavery now continue as many fight to escape its legacy in our carceral system, revealing an ongoing scheme of racialised community destabilisation and economic extraction. In this context, efforts to establish a universal basic income in the United States must not be seen as charity or even policy innovation, but as necessary reparations and redress.
The 13th Amendment did not abolish slavery – it revised it and shrouded it in secrecy. By including an exception clause allowing slavery “as punishment for a crime”, Congress preserved the legal grounds for forced labor. In the aftermath of emancipation, Southern lawmakers used the clause to criminalise everyday Black life through Black Codes and funnel newly freed people into profitable “convict leasing” programmes.
The US prison population quickly went from predominantly white to predominantly Black, with labor exploitation at the system’s core. This laid the groundwork for today’s carceral state, a brutal system that now cages over two million people. They remain unprotected from slavery, and Black Americans are incarcerated at five times the rate of white Americans.
Slavery is not just the carceral system’s history. It is its present.
Slavery Behind Prison Walls
Behind the cover of prison walls, people are forced to work in unsafe conditions for little to no pay under the threat of further punishment, including the loss of family visits – a common antebellum punishment for disobedience. Incarcerated people toil on farms, fight wildfires, sew uniforms, clean public buildings, manufacture state furniture and more, all while being denied basic labor rights and protections.
Organising is reframed as rioting to justify violent retorts that demand obedience. Just as enslaved people were reduced to tools of labor, incarcerated people are treated as disposable assets of the state – valuable only to the extent that they demonstrate compliance and generate returns.
The language used throughout our carceral system reinforces these dynamics and pays homage to the system’s roots in slavery, intentionally. Uniforms read “Sheriff’s Inmate” and paperwork labels people “Property of the State”. Solitary confinement, another common punishment for refusing to work in prison, is commonly referred to by incarcerated people and staff alike as “the hole” or “the box” – both plantation-era references to similar punishments during chattel slavery.
Even when incarcerated people are paid for their labor, they typically earn less than a dollar per hour, rates that amount to a systemic theft of labor value. A recent cost-benefit analysis estimated that between $11.6 billion and $18.8 billion is stolen from incarcerated workers in wages every year. These stolen wages represent not only lost income for incarcerated individuals, but also lost support for their children, families, and communities – further entrenching financial instability, undermining rehabilitation, and perpetuating cycles of poverty and incarceration.
The Human Cost
The cost of this centuries-long institutional racism has been devastating to Black Americans. As detailed in a new report by FWD.us, We Can’t Afford It, incarceration is costing families with incarcerated loved ones almost $350 billion each year in lost earnings and new costs, like those for phone calls, commissary goods, and medical care.
Today, nearly 50% of adults in the US have had an immediate family member incarcerated. Among Black Americans, that number is even higher: 63% have had a family member imprisoned. Black families also spend two-and-a-half times more than white families supporting incarcerated loved ones. Little changes upon release, as the over 600,000 people that return home each year in the US often find themselves burdened with debt, stripped of income, and locked out of jobs and housing.
As a result, these families are routinely forced to choose between providing for their own basic needs and supporting incarcerated loved ones. Mothers, who often serve as the primary financial and emotional support system for families impacted by incarceration, go into debt trying to do both.
One in three families with an incarcerated loved one takes on debt to pay for calls and visits alone. Children suffer the fallout in the form of housing instability, food insecurity, and eventually lost parental guidance. Nearly half of Black children in the US have had a parent incarcerated – a figure that reflects deliberate state design and intergenerational economic warfare.
The Long Road to Repair
To confront the unfinished business of abolition, Worth Rises launched the #EndTheException campaign, calling for an end to the exception in the 13th Amendment that has fuelled forced prison labor and mass incarceration more broadly since the formal abolition of chattel slavery. By demanding that the Constitution reflect a true and final end to slavery, #EndTheException lays the groundwork for broader reparative policies.
Repairing this most enduring form of racialised harm in the US requires more than acknowledgment; it demands redistribution. Reparations are the minimum, and a targeted basic income – regular, unconditional cash payments to people most impacted by incarceration – is an obvious and effective vehicle. These payments would represent a historic reversal, with public funds finally flowing into the hands of people whose wealth has been systematically stolen by state violence for generations.
The legacy of slavery cannot be separated from the institutions that followed it: convict leasing,
Redlining (the denial of services to specific neighbourhoods), Jim Crow segregation, and mass incarceration. These are not isolated chapters of history – they represent a continuous process of exploitation, extraction, and control.
Through that lens, it is easy to see that the carceral system is not broken, but functioning precisely as it was meticulously designed. Ending the exception in the 13th Amendment and providing a basic income to those impacted by it are two ways we can begin to stop and repair its harm, past and present.
This is the truth the Democrats didn’t want to acknowledge and didn’t want anyone to know. Black people knew (especially Black Men) and they hit pause on casting a ballot for Kamala. The corporate Democrats (that’s all of them since Jimmy Carter), have been a disaster for Black America, and no one should let them forget it.