Yves here. As I said to Lambert some time back regarding Biden’s big spending bills, the longer it takes to push a deal over the finishing line, the more it acquires an aura of failure. Pelosi declared that she’d have a vote (by implication at least on the infrastructure bill) by October 31. Then the deadline was moved back a few days to when Biden was flying out to the COP26 and G20 meetings, last Thursday…which then led to official shuffling and mumbling about it being OK for Biden to show up empty-handed. Now what was clear is still as clear as it was before: there’s no bargaining overlap between the positions of Senator Manchin and the House progressives.
This post usefully recaps where things stand now and reminds readers that Manchin, who is howling as if he’s being treated badly, is the one who retraded the deal.
Things could become interesting if McAuliffe loses his bid for the Virginia gubernatorial seat tomorrow. Democrat centrists will go into freakout mode. Pundits will deem the Biden Administration to be over even if the margin of loss is razor thin. But it seems unlikely that any rending of garments will move the positions of the stalemated contingents.
By Jessica Corbett. Originally published at CommonDreams
Supporters of passing the Build Back Better budget reconciliation package urged congressional progressives to maintain their position that it must move forward simultaneously with bipartisan infrastructure legislation after Sen. Joe Manchin accused his colleagues of holding the latter bill “hostage” and demanded an immediate vote.
During a Monday press conference, Manchin (D-W.Va.) said that “the political games have to stop” and called for the Democrat-held U.S. House of Representatives to swiftly vote on the infrastructure bill—which several Senate Democrats advanced in August with the expectation that it would only reach President Joe Biden’s desk alongside the reconciliation package.
“It’s time to pass a bill and quit playing games.”
— Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) with no sense of irony. pic.twitter.com/w3mvUvgRDK
— The Recount (@therecount) November 1, 2021
“Holding this bill hostage is not going to work in getting my support for the reconciliation bill,” Manchin declared, while signaling that he still does not back the compromise framework unveiled by the president last week, after intense negotiations with him and Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.), the other party member who’s pushed to weaken the legislation.
The framework that Manchin is now trashing was one he negotiated more directly with the White House than probably any other single Senator. https://t.co/aXkutmtik7
— Garrett Haake (@GarrettHaake) November 1, 2021
Manchin fell back on his long-standing concerns about the national debt and inflation, and advocated for more time to analyze the impacts of the reconciliation package, saying that “I’m open to supporting a final bill that helps move our country forward, but I am equally open to voting against a bill that hurts our country.”
The odd thing here is that Manchin is worried about budget gimmickery and waiting on a CBO score on BBB. Meanwhile, the CBO scored the BIF deal, found it added $256 billion to projected deficits and lawmakers in support of the deal (Sinema included) dismissed the CBO’s finding.
— Sam Stein (@samstein) November 1, 2021
In what The Hill described as a “veiled swipe” at Manchin, Senate Budget Committee Chair Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) on Monday addressed “anybody in the Democratic caucus or elsewhere that’s worried about fiscal responsibility and the deficit.”
“The fact is… that according to the [Congressional Budget Office] the infrastructure bill runs up to a $250 billion deficit. It’s not paid for,” Sanders told reporters on Capitol Hill. “The legislation that I wanna see passed… is paid for in its entirety. It will not have an impact on inflation. So if we’re talking about fiscal responsibility I think what we’re trying to do with the reconciliation bill is the right thing.”
Other progressive critics accused the West Virginia Democrat of personally tanking the infrastructure measure—known as the Bipartisan Infrastructure Framework (BIF)—and encouraged progressive Democrats in the House to keep fighting to pass both bills together.
Progressives are absolutely right to refuse to vote on the BIF. Manchin is a fucking snake. https://t.co/TEdAfWokk8
— David Roberts (@drvolts) November 1, 2021
Summarizing Monday’s developments, HuffPost senior politics reporter Kevin Robillard tweeted, “Just want to make sure I have the past 24 hours right: Progressives move towards doing what Joe Manchin wants, then he holds a press conference and says a bunch of stuff basically guaranteeing progressives won’t do what he wants.”
Indivisible’s Leah Greenberg responded that “Joe Manchin is doing his very best to personally tank the BIF.”
Ugh. Just nonstop bad faith from @Sen_JoeManchin, cloaked in phony pieties casting him as the only responsible party in town.
If he wants to know why people keep accusing him of operating in bad faith, look no further than what he’s saying right now. Baloney from top to bottom.
— Greg Sargent (@ThePlumLineGS) November 1, 2021
Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) chairs the Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC), which makes up about a fifth of the House. In a pair of appearances on CNN and MSNBC, she seemed optimistic that Democrats could soon send both bills to Biden for final approval.
We’re almost at the finish line. It’s time to pass the Build Back Better Act and the infrastructure bill together to make meaningful investments in working families, our communities, and protecting the planet. pic.twitter.com/4N35bQx8QB
— Rep. Pramila Jayapal (@RepJayapal) November 1, 2021
Noting the CPC’s stated support for the watered-down $1.75 trillion reconciliation legislation announced last week, Jayapal said on MSNBC that “we are now awaiting negotiations amongst senators on prescription drug pricing, and child care, and some details on immigration,” but as soon as those issues are addressed, “we will be excited to vote for both bills.”
I came to America alone at the age of 16. Since then, I’ve continually fought for immigrant rights including building the largest immigrant rights group in WA.
I’m fighting for as much as we can get on immigration reform in the Build Back Better Act because it’s time to deliver.
— Rep. Pramila Jayapal (@RepJayapal) November 1, 2021
“We are taking the president’s word at the fact that he believes he can get 50 votes in the Senate,” Jayapal said of the reconciliation package, adding that she believes Democrats are “very, very close” to passing the two long-negotiated pieces of legislation.
During the CNN segment—which came after Manchin’s brief press conference—Jayapal reportedly said she is “letting the president” deal with the West Virginia Democrat.
— Mondaire Jones (@MondaireJones) November 1, 2021
“The president says he can get 51 votes for the bill, we are going to trust him,” the CPC chair said—referring to the fact that passing the reconciliation bill in the Senate requires the support of the full Democratic caucus plus Vice President Kamala Harris. “I trust the president.”
“We will soon pass a transformational agenda that actually improves the lives of working families, creates millions of jobs, and takes bold action to save our planet,” Jayapal tweeted Monday afternoon. “People elected us to deliver, and we’re excited to do just that.”