Yves here. It’s way too easy for the middle aged and older to view the prospect of higher seas levels affecting them as too remote in time to affect them. The reality is it won’t take much change at all, in combination with higher storm surges, to affect not just residences but also critical operations, like chemical plants near the mouth of the Mississippi.
This article explains why uncertainty about Antartica makes it hard to forecast how quickly bad outcomes could materialize.
By Kristen Pope. Originally published at Yale Climate Connections
As the Earth’s climate warms, sea levels are rising, threatening to swallow coastlines and flood low-lying cities. Scientists are working to understand how much and how quickly seas could rise in coming decades – and Antarctica is one wild card.
Here are some of scientists’ most important findings from 2021 about the changes occurring in and around the world’s coldest continent.
What Happens if Antarctica Melts?
More than 97% of Antarctica is covered in ice. With a depth of up to three miles, the continent’s 6 million cubic miles of ice contain 70% of Earth’s fresh water. If all of that ice melted, the world’s oceans would rise by 200 feet (61 meters), enough to inundate Tokyo, New York City, Shanghai, and other cities.
How much the Earth’s average temperature rises is one of the main factors that will determine how Antarctic melting plays out. The climate has already warmed by roughly 1 degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit) since the late 1800s.
A 2021 study published in the journal Nature found that ice loss would likely continue at a pace similar to current patterns as long as the world does not rise more than 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 F) above pre-industrial levels.
However, if the temperature rises 3 degrees Celsius (5.4 F) or more, the paper’s authors found the rate of loss would rise to “an order of magnitude faster than today.”
Scientists use models to estimate how much the sea would rise under different scenarios. In 2021, researchers published a paper in Science Advances noting that previous estimates of impacts may be far too low. Earlier studies of the vast West Antarctic Ice Sheet had estimated that its collapse would cause global sea levels to rise by about 3.2 meters (10.5 feet). But in the new study, researchers said the collapse could actually cause the ocean to rise by an additional meter.
One-Third of Antarctic Ice Shelves Could Collapse
The fate of Antarctica’s massive ice shelves will also play a role in determining future sea-level rise. These shelves of ice jut out from Antarctica’s coastline, floating into the ocean. Importantly, they hold back the enormous glaciers that flow from the continent’s massive interior ice sheets toward the ocean.
If the Earth’s temperature were to rise to 4 degrees Celsius (7.2 F) above pre-industrial levels, a third of Antarctica’s ice shelves could become destabilized and would be at risk of collapse, according to an April 2021 paper in Geophysical Research Letters. About 193,000 square miles (500,000 square kilometers) of these ice shelves — an area slightly smaller than California and South Carolina combined — could fail. The effect of ice shelf collapse, the researchers said, would be akin to pulling a cork out of a large bottle, speeding the movement of ice into the ocean.
Some ice shelves are already melting rapidly. The George VI Ice Shelf is the second-largest ice shelf on the Antarctic Peninsula, the northernmost region of mainland Antarctica. Scientists reported that 2019-2020 was a record-breaking melt year, with “the most widespread melt” they’d seen there, though they did note they had seen longer melting seasons for the peninsula as a whole before.
Thwaites: the ‘Doomsday Glacier‘
Perhaps the most talked-about Antarctic ice story of 2021 was the potential fate of Thwaites Glacier, popularly dubbed the “Doomsday Glacier.” This massive body of ice, larger than the state of Florida, is located on the West Antarctic Ice Sheet.
In December 2021, scientists announced that cracks in the Thwaites Eastern Ice Shelf signaled that this ice shelf — which is holding back large parts of the Thwaites Glacier — could fail in as soon as five years. Without the ice shelf to stabilize it, the glacier could speed up its flow into the ocean. If the entire glacier melted, sea levels around the world would eventually rise about 25 inches (63.5 centimeters).
Pine Island Glacier Thins, Getz Region Loses Ice
Pine Island Glacier, which contains 180 trillion tons of ice, has been thinning for decades. And between the 1990s to 2009, the glacier’s flow toward the ocean accelerated from around 1.5 miles (2.4 kilometers) per year to approximately 2.5 miles (4 km) per year, staying toward the higher end of that range for around a decade. And its movement continues to speed up: Researchers published a 2021 paper in Science Advances showing that from 2017 to 2020, the rate of flow increased by around 12%.
The Getz region in West Antarctica is also showing signs of speeding up. One studypublished in Nature Communications found that most glaciers in the region were accelerating. Between 1994 and 2018, the glaciers in this region lost about 315 metric gigatons of ice.
Parker Ice Tongue Collapsed in 2020
Ice tongues are distinctive features that protrude from a glacier and can stick out far into the ocean. Normally, sea ice that is attached to land helps stabilize them and protect them from the ocean’s waves and currents. However, when sea ice disappears, the ice tongues are more vulnerable to collapse.
In March 2020, the nearly 16-square-mile (41-square-kilometer) Parker Ice Tongue fully collapsed into the western Ross Sea. In December 2021, scientists published a paper in Geophysical Research Letters detailing their findings about the event. While the authors believe that calving likely occurred on and off for many centuries in the region, this loss was massive – and unusual. The authors wrote, “A complete ice tongue collapse for these otherwise stable glaciological landmarks along the Victoria Land Coast is previously unrecorded.”
It Could Rain More Often in Antarctica
Antarctica isn’t known for rainy days. The continent’s high plateau very (very!) rarely gets rain. The northwestern Antarctica peninsula is the continent’s rainiest region, with around 50 days of rain each year.
But a 2021 study in Geophysical Research Letters found the continent’s rainfall could increase 240% by the turn of the century. The researchers also forecast more intense storms.
Liquid precipitation could cause big problems and lead to faster ice melt, especially as the insulating snow on top of the ice melts, making the ice more vulnerable.
Rain also is a threat to wildlife like penguins. Young penguin chicks are coated with downy feathers that are not rainproof. Wet chicks can freeze, especially in stormy and windy weather.
And rain is already causing problems for penguin colonies. During the 2013-2014 season, one Adélie penguin colony with about 20,000 breeding pairs failed to produce a single surviving chick. Scientists believe rain was one of the factors involved.
Melting Ice in Antarctica Could Cause Ecosystem-Wide Effects
Melting ice also changes the composition of the ocean itself. To study how the water is changing, scientists affixed data loggers to 14 seals near Pine Island Glacier, using the seals — and other methods — to gather data, including water temperature and salinity. Their results, published in Communications: Earth and Environment, suggest that when warmer meltwater rises to the top of the ocean, it can make it harder for sea ice to form, causing areas of open water. Warmer water on the surface can also lead to other ecosystem impacts.
As scientists continue to study Antarctic ice, we will learn more about how this “wild card” may affect life, not only on the Seventh Continent, but all around the world.
William Nordhaus has a new book out, so all is good.
The article has ‘if’ and ‘could’. Current observations show that the actual rate is about 5mm/year, and that the rate increases at about 0,5mm/year² (so it’s 5mm/year now, but 10mm/year in 10 years, 15 mm/year in 20 years etc.)
That gives a total raise of 336 mm (about 1 foot) by 2050, and almost 2m by 2100. One foot is major damage in many places – in the lifetime of most of us.
More details at https://tamino.wordpress.com/2021/11/29/sea-level-rising-fast/
Yes, a definite fallacy of linear extrapolation that you observe!
In that context, what strikes me is that a lot of news about the (Ant)Arctic in the last few years have been about something happening so much faster than we expect like sudden collapse of ice shelves.
There is one thing that I have sometimes wondered about the ice atop Antarctica. As the article says, in places it is 3 miles thick – nearly 5 kilometers – in places and that is so much weight that the land is actually compressed down to a significant degree. But as the ice melts, the land will rebound and I guess that this will result in tremours and earthquakes. But would these not cause even more instability and causing more ice to rapidly slide into the oceans and perhaps causing tsunamis as well as rapid sea level rises? Furthermore, as the land rebounds, mantle will once more gravitate to this region which could conceivably cause volcanoes, depending on the geology of this continent. And if there were volcanoes, the ash would encourage even more melting. Lots of possibilities here I am afraid-
From the wiki article: Due to the extreme viscosity of the mantle, it will take many thousands of years for the land to reach an equilibrium level.
There’s still rebound from the last glaciation occurring, not so long ago in geological time. I’m reasonably sure these effects will be marginal compared to the rivers flowing under the ice, lubricating the layers above. You might be interested in, though not comforted by, this note:
Seismology Gets Under the Skin of the Antarctic Ice Sheet
How about Ocean Bottom Deformations ?
Apparently the writer is not familiar with Solar Particle Forcing or Earth Magnetic field Excursion. Cliff notes summary: Fresh water melt would change global climate due to impact of ocean currents; resulting in Global Cooling. Upper atmospheric changes cause more effects than anything humans are able to accomplish.
Did the Solar Particle Forcists or the Earth Magnetic Field Excursionists make any multi-decade climate predictions the way the man made global warmists have? If so, where are they? Can you link to them?
If you could show us the actual list of climate predictions which the S P F-ists or the E M F E-ists have made, then we could see if they made the same correct predictions that the manmade global warmists have made. If your pet theorists have made the same correct predictions for their own reasons, then those reasons deserve to be studied.
Till you offer the predictions which your pet theorists have made, your comment looks like a velcro decoy tarbaby to me, set up to trick people into getting stuck to.
Meanwhile, have you considered buying land in coastal Florida or Louisiana?
Some chemical plants are near the coast and also many sewage treatment plants are sited on the coast. If the SWTs are flooded, then city’s and town’s sewer systems will stop working.
This is the tidal data from the Coast Guard Station, the Battery, south end of Manhattan. Over the last 160 years the average rise has been 1.1 inches per 10 years. Some geologists think this is still due to upstate New York rebounding from glacial ice allowing a coastal pivot where Manhattan actually sinks. There is no change to the trend. https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends_station.shtml?id=8518750
“Ifs” and “coulds”, enough to make politicians spend gobs of our money. I’d laugh but we have pressing and solvable needs more meritorious of attention.
Well, not necessarily just politicians. My coastal town is now dealing with the unseen, early stages of sea level rise: groundwater rising into the soil surrounding underground electrical utility boxes. Rust is corroding them rapidly. They now need to be replaced–with aluminum boxes the size of a small car. Costly. And since they are in a heavily traveled roadway and require substantial surrounding space for workers, they are causing traffic congestion. (Our tourists don’t like to be detained.)
The city engineers have recognized this will be an ongoing issue and have sealed the incoming and outgoing cables in PVC piping. This piping extends one block up and away from the ocean; hopefully to forestall the corroding for as long as possible. (They need to dig up these streets to install this new pipe protection.)
And to tie this comment to the housing boom (and bust), an inoperable coastal sewer plant will make most, if not all, real estate prices plunge into the depths of the sea.