Yves here. This issue, of the less-than-happy co-habitation of Ukraine refugees with native Poles, is more important than it might seem. One idea for a Ukraine endgame is to have Poland absorb neighboring parts of Ukraine, particularly the Banderist stronghold of Lvov. This idea always struck me as odd since the UkroNazis targeted and massacred Poles during World War II.
By Andrew Korybko, a Moscow-based American political analyst who specializes in the global systemic transition to multipolarity in the New Cold War. He has a PhD from MGIMO, which is under the umbrella of the Russian Foreign Ministry. Originally published at his website
The combination of many Ukrainians remaining adherents of Bandera’s ideology, their ultra-nationalists’ claims to parts of Poland, and their Ambassador to Poland’s confirmation that his co-ethnics don’t want to assimilate understandably constitute a latent national security threat to Poland.
Polish-Ukrainian relations have been increasingly strained over the past few years due to the former grain dispute, the ongoing Volhynia Genocide dispute, and the influx of Ukrainian refugees into Poland. It’s this last element that’s arguably the most sensitive since it’s become a part of daily life for most Poles. Not only do a growing number of them object to state benefits being provided to this community, but they’re also displeased with many of them refusing to assimilate into Polish society.
Ukrainian Ambassador to Poland Vasily Bodnar inadvertently made matters much worse in a recent Facebook post where he confirmed that his co-ethnics don’t want to assimilate. The context concerns the state’s decision over the summer to allow Ukrainian to be taught as the second foreign language in schools if parents request it, the human resources are available, and the school gives its approval. Some Poles are concerned that this move will exacerbate existing societal divisions if implemented at scale.
Bodnar was responding to these concerns, referencing the abovementioned law and Ukrainian refugees’ contribution to the Polish economy among other points, when he misguidedly added that “We want to help our children preserve our identity, contribute to their return home to Ukraine when the security situation allows it. We are for socialization and integration, but it is clear that we are not for assimilation. Most of our refugees are not here of their own will but because of an ongoing terrible war.”
While also writing how “grateful” they are, the above post suggested that they’re not “grateful” enough to only learn Polish and thus fully assimilate. Post-WWII Poland became one of the world’s most homogenous societies, which was the first time in this over-millennium-old civilization-state’s history that it was almost exclusively ethnic Polish and Roman Catholic since it began incorporating East Slavs and Orthodox Christians in the late 10th century, only for this to abruptly change from 2022 onwards.
Even though Bodnar insisted that “we have no intentions of interfering in the internal affairs of Poland”, leader of the “Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists” (OUN) Bogdan Chervak ominously warned last fall that “Poles are playing with fire” in response to a shitpost map of Greater Poland on social media. That scandal was analyzed here and included a warning about how Ukrainian ultra-nationalists inspired by former OUN chief Stepan Bandera might resort to terrorism to advance their own claims to Poland.
Last month’s Bandera flag scandal in Warsaw’s largest stadium prompted President Karol Nawrocki to propose a law that would criminalize Bandera’s anti-Polish ideologywhose adherents carried out the Volhynia Genocide of over 100,000 Poles. The combination of this ideology’s continued prevalence among Ukrainians, their ultra-nationalists’ claims to parts of Poland, and Bodnar’s confirmation that his co-ethnics don’t want to assimilate understandably constitute a latent national security threat.
Therefore, while Ukrainian can legally be taught as the second foreign language in Polish schools, Nawrocki and his allies would do well to discourage them from approving such requests on national security grounds. It would be best if the law was changed, but the ruling liberal-globalist coalition might not support such an initiative from the conservative opposition. One way or another, Poland must ensure that all Ukrainians assimilate, otherwise they might one day threaten its territorial integrity.
Strangely omits that the reason that Poland became monoethnic after WWII is that the Jews were killed and Germans ethnically cleansed.
“It would be best if the law was changed, but the ruling liberal-globalist coalition might not support such an initiative from the conservative opposition.”
Just as a point of comparison, in the Baltic states, Russian is being phased out as a language of instruction (Estonia, Lithuania), and even as a foreign language (Latvia, Lithuania), despite substantial Russophone minorities established in those countries for generations, and without a peep from the “liberal-globalists”.
Double standards, again and again…
If Poland were to annex part of Ukraine, the Ukrainians living in the annexed region would immediately enjoy the benefits. They would gain EU and NATO membership and a significantly higher standard of living. In contrast, Poland would only gain access to a large pool of low-wage laborers.
The population of Poland is approximately 38 million people while there are anything up to 2 million Ukrainians living in Poland at the moment. What that means is that for every 19 people that you see in Poland, odds are that one of them is actually a Ukrainian. The refusal of so many Ukrainians to assimilate is concerning as it is not that hard to learn a second language. I have met very young Dutch schoolkids that could talk Dutch, English, German & French for example. Perhaps they have been kidding themselves about not needing to learn Polish as any day now, the Russians will go into full retreat and they will be able to return home victorious to their country. But I can understand how they could be seen as a security threat. As an example, look at how post-WW2 so many hard-liners went to Canada and have infiltrated that society and entering government services (cough*Freeland*cough) to change that country’s social direction. Hard-core Ukrainians are supremacists at heart and would not look kindly at Poland. You can bet that Poles would know all this.
This is a problem for the whole of Europe
One may hope that the Ukronazis will turn on themselves in internal power struggles before they can harm the societies (c.f. Parubiy).
https://www.jungewelt.de/loginFailed.php?ref=/artikel/469335.nazi-organisationen-h%C3%B6llensturm-f%C3%BCr-den-feind.html
https://thegrayzone.com/2024/04/07/centuria-ukraines-western-neo-nazi-army/
https://fondfbr.ru/en/articles/centuria-german-eu-uk-en/